Supernatural has been the little show that could at The CW – never getting the buzz of other series on the network like Gossip Girl, but holding onto a loyal fanbase, and even seeing an increase in its ratings as the current fourth season began.

While it's seen as highly likely that the show will be renewed for a fifth season, it hasn't been confirmed as of yet. Yesterday, I asked The CW's President of Entertainment, Dawn Ostroff, if fans could count on seeing the Winchester brothers again next fall. Ostroff told me, "It's too early to say," noting that the fall schedule wouldn't be announced until May. She added, "Creatively, we've been really happy with the show and the show's been holding its own, so I hope it continues to do well, because I'd love to see it back."